Charles Ryrie vs C.I. Scofield Study Bible: What’s the Difference?


The Scofield Study Bible and the Ryrie Study Bible are two of the most popular Christian reference resources of the last century. There are similarities between the Study Bibles because both men were devout, dispensational pretribulationist premillennialists, which their study notes reflect. Yet they have differences as well.

The Scofield Study Bible and the Ryrie Study Bible are two classic resources that teach dispensational premillennial eschatology. Scofield’s original study notes also teach the Gap Theory of creation and utilize Bishop James Ussher’s timeline of history, which Ryrie’s notes don’t.

What makes the Scofield and Ryrie Study Bibles so special? Why do people like them so much? What exactly is dispensational premillennialism? Keep reading to learn more.

For more Study Bible comparisons, see the Study Bible Comparison Chart, which contrasts dozens of volumes on one page.

Study bible with notes
“Then I saw heaven opened, and behold, a white horse! The one sitting on it is called Faithful and True, and in righteousness he judges and makes war.” Revelation 19:1 (ESV)

Scofield and Ryrie: comparison

The publication of the Scofield Study Bible was a seminal event with regard to resurrecting a centuries-old way to teach the Bible (i.e. including explanatory notes and commentary) and the proliferation of dispensational premillennial eschatology.

  • Scofield’s Study Bible followed in the tradition of the 16th century Geneva Study Bible, which contained notes to help explain Scripture. Today, there are hundreds of Study Bibles on the market, thanks in part to the success Scofield’s work had, which influenced later generations.
  • Scofield’s Study Bible became a tremendously popular resource in his day and was used in churches, Bible schools, and went overseas with missionaries. As the Study Bible grew in popularity, so did dispensational premillennialism (see a summary below).

Scofield’s Study Bible influenced many leading pastors and theologians, and impacted millions of Christians who read it regularly, like Charles Ryrie.

To understand the difference between the Scofield and Ryrie Study Bibles, it’s important to understand the differences between the men’s lives and ministries. There are more similarities than differences between the books. The comparison table below offers key information about each man.

C.I. ScofieldCharles Ryrie
Lived: 1843-1921Lived: 1925-2016
Education: unknown; later in life signed his name “DD” for Doctor of DivinityEducation: Master’s and Doctorate of Theology, Dallas Theological Seminary
Ministry: Pastored in Congregational, Reformed churchesMinistry: Taught at Dallas Theological Seminary and others schools
Cairn University: founderCairn University: president of Cairn from 1958-1962
Dwight Moody: served with MoodyDwight Moody: Study Bible published by Moody Press
Study Bible published: 1909Study Bible published: 1976
Theology: theologically conservativeTheology: theologically conservative
Eschatology: dispensational premillennialismEschatology: dispensational premillennialism

There are many different kinds of Study Bibles. See Study Bible vs Reference Bible: What’s the Difference? for more.

Scofield and Ryrie: key differences

The Gap Theory: Scofield’s Study Bible teaches the Gap Theory of creation in its notes on Genesis 1. The Gap Theory suggests that there is a “gap” of geologic time between Genesis 1:2 and Genesis 1:3. The Gap Theory is often contrasted with other views on natural order, including Young Earth creationism, Old Earth creationism, and various evolutionary theories. Ryrie’s Study Bible doesn’t advocate for the Gap Theory.

Scofield’s note on Genesis 1:2 reflects The Gap Theory: “clearly indicate that the earth had undergone a cataclysmic change as the result of divine judgment. The face of the earth bears everywhere the marks of such a catastrophe. There are not wanting imitations which connect it with a previous testing and fall of angels.”

Ussher’s timeline of history: James Ussher (1581-1656), an Irish Anglican bishop, is best known for teaching that God created the Earth on October 23, 4004 B.C. Some Christians agreed with Ussher’s teaching, including Scofield. The 1967 “New Scofield Study Bible” removed the teaching, but later editions placed it back in the study notes. Ryrie’s Study Bible doesn’t include Ussher’s timeline.

King James Version: Scofield original (or “Old”) Study Bible, published in 1909, used the King James version of the Bible. So, too, did the revised edition of 1917. Scofield died in 1921. An eight-person committee revised the Study Bible in 1967. The “New” edition, also called “Scofield III,” comes in a variety of English translations. Ryrie’s Study Bible also comes in a variety of English translations, like the KJV, NJKV, NIV, ESV, and NASB.

Also see Is a Study Bible Good to Use? for more.

What is dispensational premillennialism?

The word “premillennialism” refers to the belief that Jesus will return to Earth prior to the 1,000-year period described in Revelation 20:1-6.

Premillennilaism is often contrasted with amillennialism, which literally means “no millennium,” yet it’s the belief that the 1,000-year period described in Revelation 20 is the time between Christ’s first and second coming. Amillennialism, therefore, interprets 1,000 figuratively.

Premillennialism is also contrasted with postmillennialism, which is the belief that Jesus’ Second Coming will occur at the end of the 1,000-year reign of Christ. Postmillennialists interpret the 1,000 literally, however they hold to a different end-time chronology than premillennialism.

“And I saw an angel coming down out of heaven, having the key to the Abyss and holding in his hand a great chain. 2 He seized the dragon, that ancient serpent, who is the devil, or Satan, and bound him for a thousand years. 3 He threw him into the Abyss, and locked and sealed it over him, to keep him from deceiving the nations anymore until the thousand years were ended. After that, he must be set free for a short time.”

Revelation 20:1-3 (ESV, epmhasis added)

There are many Premillennial Bible commentaries of Revelation that are well-reviewed. See Best Revelation commentaries for more.

“The millennium is a thousand years of peace that Christians like to fight about.”

Anonymous

What is dispensationalism?

A dispensation refers to era of times. Dispensationalism interprets Scripture in a manner that divides history into different eras. Scofield defines the term this way:

“A dispensation is a period of time during which man is tested in re­spect of obedience to some specific revelation of the will of God. Seven such dispensations are dis­tinguished in Scripture.”

Scofield Study Bible, pg. 5

Not all dispensationalists count the eras the same way, however the classic view, which is Scofield’s, sees seven in total:

  • Innocence
  • Conscience
  • Government
  • Promise
  • Law
  • Grace
  • Kingdom/millennium

Premillennialism: The order of major end times events

  • The rapture: The rapture is the first, and next event on God’s end times schedule. The rapture refers to the sudden, supernatural removal of Christians from the Earth. Premillennialism teaches that the rapture could happen at any moment — even today.
  • The tribulation: The seven-year tribulation period follows the rapture (though it isn’t triggered by it). Dispensational premillennialists believe it’s described in Revelation 6-19. During the tribulation, the Holy Spirit is removed from the Earth and the Antichrist and False Prophet wreck havoc upon people. The period ends with the Battle of Armageddon.
  • The Second Coming: Christ’s return to Earth follows Armageddon and the tribulation period. He will judge the Earth and establish his 1,000-year millennial kingdom described in Revelation 20:1-6. All eschatological views hold to the return of Christ, but there isn’t agreement about when it will occur.
  • The millennium: Dispensational premillennialist believe the 1,000-year period is literal and in the future. Other views believe it is occurring in the present and that the number is figurative.
  • The eternal state: Also called the Final State, it’s the last period of time — which lasts for all eternity — in which people are either in heaven or hell.

Many Christians use devotional Bibles for their daily reading. See What is a Devotional Bible? to learn more.

References:
[1] Source
[2] Source
[3] Source
[4] Source

Daniel Joseph Isaiah

Daniel has been in Christian ministry for 25 years. He has been an Associate Pastor and a Senior Pastor. Currently in higher education, Daniel has taught more than 25 different undergraduate courses in Bible and theology-related topics.

Recent Posts